We'd appreciate your feedback. Send feedback Subscribe to our newsletters and alerts


Entomological Research Letters

2022 Volume 2 Issue 1
Creative Commons License

Treating Species Delimitation as Model Choice Can Make Integrative Insect Systematics More Transparent and Reproducible


, , ,
  1. Department of Model-Based Species Delimitation, Faculty of Biosciences, Federal University of Minas Gerais, Belo Horizonte, Brazil.
  2. Department of Transparent Systematics and Model Choice, Faculty of Life Sciences, University of Coimbra, Coimbra, Portugal.
  3. Department of Reproducible Taxonomy and Integrative Methods, Faculty of Sciences, University of São Paulo, São Paulo, Brazil.
Abstract

Integrative insect systematics increasingly combines mitochondrial barcodes, multilocus or genomic data, morphology, geography, ecology and reproductive information, yet species-delimitation outputs are still often presented as if they directly reveal species boundaries. This methodological framework argues that delimitation is more transparent when treated as model choice: investigators specify competing species hypotheses, state the assumptions connecting each evidence class to those hypotheses, compare evidential support, preserve discordance, test sensitivity to priors and thresholds, and report uncertainty before taxonomic action. The framework does not privilege a single species concept or algorithm. Instead, it separates observed evidence, process assumptions, statistical support and taxonomic interpretation. Insect case studies show why this separation matters: coalescent partitions can track population structure, gene flow can blur boundaries, mitochondrial and nuclear signals can disagree, and apparently concordant evidence can still remain conditional on sampling and analytical choices. The proposed architecture therefore treats species delimitation as an auditable sequence of competing explanations rather than an automatic conversion of clusters into names. Its purpose is methodological reproducibility, not universal taxonomic resolution.


How to cite this article
Vancouver
Costa G, Ribeiro L, Alves R, Lopes M. Treating Species Delimitation as Model Choice Can Make Integrative Insect Systematics More Transparent and Reproducible. Entomol Res Lett. 2022;2(1):118-27. https://doi.org/10.51847/AZSzOenOnW
APA
Costa, G., Ribeiro, L., Alves, R., & Lopes, M. (2022). Treating Species Delimitation as Model Choice Can Make Integrative Insect Systematics More Transparent and Reproducible. Entomological Research Letters, 2(1), 118-127. https://doi.org/10.51847/AZSzOenOnW

About ESVPUB

Find out more

Since 2020, Eurasia Specialized Veterinary Publication has been dedicated to publishing rigorous scientific research in veterinary medicine, entomology, animal health, and related disciplines. Our journals offer a peer-reviewed home for original research, review articles, and short communications, spanning veterinary and clinical sciences, animal health and disease management, pathology, pharmacology, diagnostics, zoonotic diseases, epidemiology, and public health. Our entomology titles bring together work on insect biology, ecology and behavior, taxonomy and systematics, physiology, biodiversity and conservation, pest management, and medical and veterinary entomology. We also welcome interdisciplinary research that explores the connections between animal, human, insect, and environmental health — work that reflects the reality that these fields rarely stand apart from one another. In all that we publish, our aim remains the same: to support the exchange of meaningful, practical scientific knowledge within the international research community.