We'd appreciate your feedback. Send feedback Subscribe to our newsletters and alerts


Entomological Research Letters

2022 Volume 2 Issue 2
Creative Commons License

Conflict Among Genomic Markers in Insect Radiations Often Contains Biological Signal Rather Than Merely Analytical Noise


, ,
  1. Department of Genomic Conflict and Biological Signal, Faculty of Biosciences, Stellenbosch University, Stellenbosch, South Africa.
  2. Department of Phylogenomic Discordance and Radiations, Faculty of Life Sciences, University of Pretoria, Pretoria, South Africa.
Abstract

Genome-scale datasets have increased phylogenetic resolution across insects, but they have also exposed persistent disagreement among loci, gene trees and genomic regions. Such discordance is often treated as an analytical defect to be filtered, down-weighted or overwhelmed by additional data. This perspective argues that this response is incomplete. In rapidly diversifying insect lineages, conflict can instead record incomplete lineage sorting, introgression, gene duplication and loss, or heterogeneous histories within genomic regions, although the same observable patterns may also arise from gene-tree estimation error, model misspecification, alignment problems, locus construction or contamination. We therefore distinguish observed discordance from explanations for discordance and from the stronger inference of species history. Evidence from aphids, bumblebees, drosophilids, butterflies, dragonflies, damselflies and other insect groups shows that genuine biological conflict can persist in large phylogenomic datasets, whereas methodological studies demonstrate that apparently convincing conflict may also be analytical. The central proposal is consequently not to privilege biological explanations, but to treat discordance as an inferential object requiring explicit validation. A staged interpretation of marker conflict can preserve biological information while reducing premature mechanistic attribution, indiscriminate filtering and unsupported taxonomic conclusions.


How to cite this article
Vancouver
Botha P, Wyk AV, Marais J. Conflict Among Genomic Markers in Insect Radiations Often Contains Biological Signal Rather Than Merely Analytical Noise. Entomol Res Lett. 2022;2(2):57-66. https://doi.org/10.51847/EaT9yRjUgL
APA
Botha, P., Wyk, A. V., & Marais, J. (2022). Conflict Among Genomic Markers in Insect Radiations Often Contains Biological Signal Rather Than Merely Analytical Noise. Entomological Research Letters, 2(2), 57-66. https://doi.org/10.51847/EaT9yRjUgL

About ESVPUB

Find out more

Since 2020, Eurasia Specialized Veterinary Publication has been dedicated to publishing rigorous scientific research in veterinary medicine, entomology, animal health, and related disciplines. Our journals offer a peer-reviewed home for original research, review articles, and short communications, spanning veterinary and clinical sciences, animal health and disease management, pathology, pharmacology, diagnostics, zoonotic diseases, epidemiology, and public health. Our entomology titles bring together work on insect biology, ecology and behavior, taxonomy and systematics, physiology, biodiversity and conservation, pest management, and medical and veterinary entomology. We also welcome interdisciplinary research that explores the connections between animal, human, insect, and environmental health — work that reflects the reality that these fields rarely stand apart from one another. In all that we publish, our aim remains the same: to support the exchange of meaningful, practical scientific knowledge within the international research community.