We'd appreciate your feedback. Send feedback Subscribe to our newsletters and alerts



2024 Volume 4 Issue 2
Creative Commons License

Economic Evaluation of Biopesticides vs. Chemical Insecticides: Impact on Cotton Farming in South Africa


,
  1. South African Sugarcane Research Institute, Private Bag X02, Mount Edgecombe, 4300, South Africa.
  2. Agricultural Research Council –Industrial Crops, Private Bag X82075, Rustenburg, 0300, South Africa.
  3. School of Agricultural, Earth and Environmental Sciences, University of KwaZulu-Natal, Private Bag X01, Scottsville, Pietermaritzburg, 3209, South Africa.
Abstract

Cotton plays an important role in Africa's agricultural economy, yet its profitability is often challenged by high production costs. This study evaluates the cost-effectiveness of chemical insecticides—Chlorpyrifos® 480 EC, Karate® EC, and Bandit® 350 SC—against biopesticides—Eco-Bb®, Bolldex®, Delfin®, Nomu-Protec®, and Bb endophyte—in managing cotton pests. Among the tested pesticides, Delfin® incurred the highest expense at US$602, followed by Bolldex® at US$495.74, while Chlorpyrifos® was the most economical at US$28. Additional production costs amounted to US$1,396.50 per hectare, with labor being the most significant at US$544. The lowest production expenditure in the bollworm was observed with Karate® (US$1,455), whereas Delfin® had the highest (US$1,999). Bolldex® achieved the highest cotton yield (6,402 kg ha⁻¹), but Karate® had the greatest net profit (US$1,445.26 per hectare) and the best cost-benefit ratio (1.8). In the leafhopper, Bandit® produced the highest average seed cotton yield (6,394 kg ha⁻¹), followed by Bb endophyte (6,297 kg ha⁻¹). Net profit was highest with Bandit® (US$1,712), followed by Karate® (US$1,253), with Bandit® yielding the highest cost-benefit ratio (2). While biopesticides generally required higher investment than chemical insecticides, all treatments were financially viable.


How to cite this article
Vancouver
Malinga L, Laing M. Economic Evaluation of Biopesticides vs. Chemical Insecticides: Impact on Cotton Farming in South Africa. Entomol Lett. 2024;4(2):22-33. https://doi.org/10.51847/0dYZdyeQRm
APA
Malinga, L., & Laing, M. (2024). Economic Evaluation of Biopesticides vs. Chemical Insecticides: Impact on Cotton Farming in South Africa. Entomology Letters, 4(2), 22-33. https://doi.org/10.51847/0dYZdyeQRm
Related articles:
Biting Midge Fauna (Diptera: Simuliidae) Across Russia
Entomology Letters
Vol 4 Issue 2, 2024 | Olga Alexandrovna Fiodorova
Most viewed articles:
Synthetic Acaricides in Tick Control Programs: An Overview of Present Applications
International Journal of Veterinary Research and Allied Sciences
Vol 1 Issue 1, 2021 | K R. Reshma
The Impact of Cold Storage on the Survival and Viability of Parasitoid Bee Pupae and Whole Insects
International Journal of Veterinary Research and Allied Sciences
Vol 4 Issue 2, 2024 | Jianjun Mao
Understanding the Biological Characteristics and Diagnostic Approaches for Escherichia coli and Colibacillosis
International Journal of Veterinary Research and Allied Sciences
Vol 3 Issue 2, 2023 | Amyleigh Watts
Evaluation of Urtica dioica Extract as a Protective Agent against Hepatic and Renal Toxicity Induced by Insecticides
International Journal of Veterinary Research and Allied Sciences
Vol 1 Issue 1, 2021 | Mongi Saoudi
Modulation of Hormonal Homeostasis and Blood Biochemical Markers by Non-Hormonal Drugs
International Journal of Veterinary Research and Allied Sciences
Vol 3 Issue 2, 2023 | Cristina Mennitti
The Role of Synovial Fluid Morphology in Joint Lubrication and Function
International Journal of Veterinary Research and Allied Sciences
Vol 4 Issue 2, 2024 | Max Marian

About ESVPUB

Find out more

Eurasia Specialized Veterinary Publication is an esteemed scientific publisher dedicated to advancing knowledge across veterinary medicine, entomology, and allied scientific disciplines. We focus on delivering high-impact scholarly content that addresses a broad range of theoretical and applied topics.

Our publications include original research articles, research notes, and comprehensive reviews spanning the diverse field of veterinary science. Key areas of focus include anatomy, physiology, biochemistry, pharmacology, microbiology, pathology, parasitology, clinical sciences, public health, and veterinary education.

Recognizing the growing importance of insect-related research in veterinary and ecological contexts, our scope also encompasses entomology, including studies on vector-borne diseases, insect-pathogen interactions, and integrated pest management.

We actively seek high-quality submissions that are rigorous in methodology and contribute meaningful insights to the advancement of veterinary and biological sciences. Our mission is to provide a reliable and dynamic platform for scientific exchange that benefits researchers, clinicians, and educators around the world.